Wow I love this stuff! It's a two sided gloss and matching liner pencil in one. The gloss goes on smooth without being sticky and it has that same color changing effect as the Virtual Eyes shadows! Down to Earth is a brown that flashes hints of green color and goes on beautifully, looks just like the loose e/s! Then again I always like weird l/g colors, MAC squirt is one of my favorites! LOL Anywat I bought these off of the PF website for only $2.99 each, I've never seen them in the stores either, so maybe they're discontinued?