I have this pencil in Silver Green, which was part of the 2010 birthday BI kit. The dusty sea green brings out the green in my eyes and goes well with several of the cool greens in my shadow collection. It goes on a little waxy, which is a good thing because it thus has lasting power, although that also makes it too hard to use it on inner rims.Oddly, the pencil does not fit in any of my cosmetic pencil sharpeners. It is a smidge too fat for the little hole, and way too small for the large hole. I end up having to sharpen it in a sharpener meant for office pencils. Very poorly designed, Sephora.

So I guess these are discontinued which sucks because these were my all time favorite eye liners. I had the black 91 and a blueish gray color. I need to figure out if they just changed the name. I bought 2 of the sephora nano liners thinking they would be good replacements. I was wrong. They are a total waste of money.

I have this e/l in black. It's very average in quality and doesn't have the best staying power. I would not repurchase.

I absolutely loved these liners and had them in taupe, charcoal grey, bronze and metallic olive. WHY did they change the colors? I think they changed the formula, too. If you noticed, they phased out the old ones about 6 months ago. Recently, I bought the "navy" online and it is awful. Crazy amount of color and took forever to get off. Not to mention that it is much more royal blue than navy. The brown seems to have the same problem - too much runny color. Disappointed at the changes - if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

wow! my favorite liner of all time! and plus it has such a great price.

I have this pencil in White. I've only used it a couple of times so far (on the waterline) but I am impressed with the quality of the product, esp. for the price. It is extremely pigmented and stays on a very long time. Even after I washed my makeup off there was still some on my waterline. I will definitely purchase this pencil in more colors.

This eyeliner is amazing. Its creamy, and blendable but still looks amazing on your waterline. I love the variety of colors this comes in!!

And for 5 dollars?!?!?! great STEAL!

Pretty good. This line is good if there's a crazy color you're looking for but don't wanna make the commitment of spending $16 on some other brand. It goes on pretty smoothly with only the slightest hint of raccoonage after a few hours. Only thing is I thought it would be longer, it's only like 4-5 inches long. I dunno, I think Jordana liners are a better value.

My HG eyeliner. It's nice and creamy, glides on smooth, stays put, and is only $5! Why even try drugstore eyeliners or something more expensive? Plus it comes in a variety of colors if you want colorful eyeliners (I stay with basic black for myself).

Just bought this yesterday and I love it. I had been looking for a deep purple liner to bring out my green eyes and finally found this one. I love how they have tons of colors and for the price of $5, I think I have found my new HG eyeliner! Lasts all day, smudges well, never flakes, looks awesome, I love it! I would recommend this liner to everyone and will be buying again! I love Sephora!