This is a pale metallic blue, I love it! I have it and twinkle. It might wear off within a few hours but I can easily put more back on! So it gets 4 lippies for that, other than that it's great!
Metallic Stars is a loose powder shadow in a rollerball bottle. It's a neat idea - although application is not that precise, at least the shadow doesn't fly around everywhere like loose powder in pots. Star Gaze is a classic frosted pale blue. Unfortunately, although it goes on beautifully, it fades away to nothing but a sparkle trail in a couple of hours. This is so often the difference between cheap makeup and quality stuff, and in the end I often wish, as I do here, that I'd not been so mean and just shelled out on a decent brand in the first place. I guess it's a useful (clean, tidy and applicator-free) way to carry around eyeshadow though.