This sucked. It did nothing for my lashes. I have long lashes and somehow they managed to look so clumpy they actually lost all length.

The mascara doesn't apply as a liquid, more as a series of clumps. If you have sensitive eyes, avoid this like the plague; my eyes would puff up and start to tear within minutes of applying. Another crappy mascara from Revlon...maybe they should just stick to lips.....

A very lack luster product from Revlon. The formula is dry and slightly thick. This mascara wears well but that is the end of its good qualities. It give no length or thickness. It takes repeated coats to even show up at all.
I have long but thin eyelashes and this did nothing to improve their appearance.

Will not buy again.

I was so disappointed with this product that I don't even want to try Revoln mascaras in the future, they often are a fail but this one really takes the prize. The clumps begin days after the tube is opened, and good luck getting this off your eyes even with baby oil, I lost lashes because of this gooey mess of a product, I was so upset that I had to treat myself to something recommended and great - Diorshow after how badly this performed. I rarely see a mascara get this dry and clumpy so fast, it must have worked overtime to get this cruddy. In the trash it goes after two weeks of use, not hanks.

At first this mascara was fine. Good coverage, thick lashes and no flaking. However because it is long wearing, the formula thickens up in the tube really quickly. I always replace my mascara every 3 months for hygiene reasons but this one I had to replace earlier because of how dry and clumpy the formula became.

This mascara is one of hte worst.
IT doesn't make your lashes any thicker or any more volumized, it only gives them colro and that's all.
PLus it flakes really easily, and at school I usually have dark falkes or circles under my eyes.
I always have to check if I do.
I hate it.
This eyeliner seems pretty dry.
Once I put it on, it starts flaking.
I would never recommed this to anyone,
and wouldn't but it again.

i am still working through a tube of this, i wear it on days nobody else is going to be at work (well, nobody cute or .
interesting).

this product works okay for its price range.

It does smudge and flake off, but only a little bit, even though my skin is pretty oily.

Right off the bat, this does wear off on the lashes near the edge of the eye, like the corners of my eye near my nose. I just remember that after i put it on, i need to do a mirror check in 15 minutes, and i need to do a mirror check after i laugh too hard.

this product does nothing for length or volume. its only claim is that it stays on, and it only does that okay.

i think Revlon spent too much money on the actual product, and not advertising or packaging. Theres no gimicks or pretty packaging, which i respect, but even with the money they skimped on all that, they still failed to make a great product.

The one thing i do like about this product is that the black brown is actually a black brown, and looks that way. alot of black browns just seem to be black on me, or a muted black, or are too brown. this is a good balance. The color is great, now if only they could get the mascara to actually "stay" (colorstay), Revlon could make some money.

this mascara smudge a lot, and the dried up mascara bits always went on my face. It always clumped and it looks kind of gross. I mean, it's just plain mascara. nothing speccial about it. It's ok, if you have nothing else, but ONLY if you have no other mascara.

It's been a few years since I've used Colorstay mascara, so I don't remember much, but I can remember not being very impressed by it. I always used to buy the foundation, and I figured that since this mascara was a bit more expensive the quality would be better. I guess I was wrong. I can't remember anything about this mascara except the fact that I could never get it off my eyelashes. Never. I literally had to pull the dried mascara off my eyelashes. EW! You might like this mascara if you like pulling out your lashes, or want to paint your lashes with black spackle in a small tube, because that's pretty much all this is.

I agree with the other reviewers who complained about dry, brittle lashes. That definitely was the case for me, but I suppose it has something to do with leaving the product on for several days. The product smudges slightly each day that you're wearing it, too. And it's flake city with this stuff too...I like the convenience of being able to put it on and not worry about it for a few days, but it's ridiculously difficult to remove if you want it off before then. I sort of had this brief love affair with this mascara because I thought I would like the daytime mascara look without the fuss of daily application, but I am just so accustomed to wearing mascara only on special occasions that it's not the product for me. It also has a wicked tendency to clump on my lashes. Since I rarely wear mascara, I'd rather wear the conventional waterproof formula that you remove at the end of the day.