The best thing about this is that it glides so smoothly it doesn't irritate my (sensitive) eyes at all. It's ok for tightlining but not for the waterline &it's pretty pigmented. This product smudges pretty easily (which isn't what I personally want but I guess it's good if you want a smudged look) but the good thing is that when it smudges, it doesn't go all over the place (it just disappears like nothing was there before). I don't mind reapplying so this is okay with me (although I probably won't repurchase once I find something better) continued >>

Been using one version or another of this since I was 8 and raided my sister's makeup bag. Soft, heavily pigmented, smudgable, inexpensive. If you're just starting out in makeup and have the coloring to use black eyeliner I strongly recommend this as a first purchase.. Make sure you've got a strategy for removing it or you'll be panda eyes in the morning.

I really love this eyeliner.


The consistency is lovely and glides on smoothly. Smudges well but also holds a nice line. I am terrible with using pencils to line my upper lid, but often use this pencil on my waterline and to tightline.


It stays put for hours and looks great. The black is very dark and opaque and stays that way.


This pencil comes with a cap and must be sharpened, but the tip is thin and smooth when sharpened. My only caution is to be careful putting the cap on--if you really shove it on, it can smoosh the tip of the liner and make a large mess. You do not need to shove the cap on for it to stay firmly. I have never had the cap come off in a makeup bag.


I also have the White. I use it under colorful, bright shadows to make them pop. I swipe it lightly across my lower waterline to give my eyes a wider, brighter effect when I don't wear other eyeliner.


This is a quality eyeliner for the price. I will be purchasing this again and again.

This eyeliner is my baby. With very little effort, you can create a perfectly smudged smokey eye. It's also great to put in your waterline. It's pigmented, it's a flawless texture, it's just amazing.

I love how this eyeliner is really soft and that's the main reason why I have re purchased it, its great for tightlining. However I have found that it does smudge and fade from my waterline :( I'm sure there are better liners out there for waterline but for the softness of the pencil, I would buy it again for tightlinng! (Something I can't leave the house without doing)

In my opinion this is the best Pencil you can buy. I have never had a smudging problem and it lasts for a long time.

I adore this eyeliner! I stumbled across this liner a few months back and have repurchased it at least 5 times! I have it in jet black and also in white and I can’t get over how well it works. It’s under $10 and it stays put all day even if I wear it on my water line. The only con is it is a pencil so I have to sharpen it which can get annoying but the quality makes up for it! If you’re thinking of buying it, GO FOR IT! Great buy, you will not be disappointed! <3 continued >>

I've bought this liner countless times! The black is perfect for lining my waterline. It is very easy to apply, and smudges nicely on the upper line also. Perfect for smokey eyes!

I got this with a Rimmel mascara, otherwise I wouldn't have even given this a try.
This eye liner is AMAZING! It doesn't transfer, it doesn't smudge and it goes on easily! I mostly use it for tight lining and it stays put.
It's really pigmented and soft at the same time.
There isn't anything special about the packaging, just a pencil with a cap on it.
At the moment, I can't think of any reason not to love this eye liner.
I would definitely repurchase this when I run out!

Useless, transfers from water line, smudges too easily, panda eyes a go-go.