I love the gilimmersticks eyeliners,never will ever use anything else for my precious eyes,goes on smoothly,easy to reapply, does not smudge,removes with gentle cleansers, have been buying them for around 10 yrs now!!

I got this from the Avon catalog, 4 for $10, an amazing price. Right away I swatched it, and I immediately loved the color. It glides on super easily, and I love how it self-sharpens. My only complaints is that it wears off after a few hours and there was less product than I was expecting.

My go to brown eyeliner. Works better than any pencil I have used and I love the self sharpener, it goes on easily and lasts a pretty long time.

This is my HG brown liner! I have been buying this since my early teen years and I still love it! It is my go-to for everyday wear. I have sensitive eyes and this never irritates my eyes! The line size of the pencil is perfect, you don't have to tug at your eyes as the application is always smooth and it has great lasting power! They often have these on sell, but they are well worth full price. Love this product and will be a loyal user as long as they sell it!

I agree with others who've said it's not great on the waterline...it will slip and smudge your undereye area...but if you use it to line your upper eye, you should be good to go. You can always set it with eyeshadow if you have problems with fading---not on your waterline though! This one is really smooth and I love the color, it's great for day/work.

I bought this on sale because I wanted to try out a new eyeliner. I do love the color and it glides on very smoothly without any tugging, plus it's creamy too. The color comes off dark and you don't need to reapply to get more color onto your lids. The only bad thing is that it doesn't stay on the waterline...It'll fade out in less than two hours! And then it smudges/runs later on in the day if you put it on the lower lashline.
What I don't like it that while I'm applying, sometimes it twists back down...A bit annoying.

I have used this eyeliner for the last 5 years+. I don't stray from brown much but have purchased it in black once or twice. The color is a dark brown. You twist up the pencil everytime it gets low, no sharpening required. I love that. And this pencil is so creamy and easy to smudge as well. I use this every single day and will never fall out of love with this little pencil. Will repurchase.

This is almost always in my makeup bag. Cosmic brown is the perfect color for me. This eyeliner is smooth and creamy going on. It lasts just ok. You can get this for a steal when Avon runs promotions, so I ususally buy two.

i really love these because they are super soft and the are retractable no sharpening needed! i have this in blackest black, cosmic brown and from another collection in starry night. i have two blackest black soo i always throw one in my makeup bag. this is really good for the water line but fade a little throughout the day. i would absolutely repurchase again.

This is the only dark brown eyeliner that actually looks dark brown on me. I'm medium skintoned so brown liners either look black or very light brown and dont define the eyes. I love this shade, and it stays all day!! Its very affordable too.