WOW !

Easy to apply- smooth
Good pigmentation
Blendable,
Smudgable
Wipeoff-able
Great colours
Affordable
Non irritating

I think I am recommend these.

This is a quite good, easy to apply eyeliner. I'm using the black one and it's one of the best eyeliners I've used. It doesn't smudge. It's good for the price. I would buy it again.

pigmented, quite cheap, quite soft but not that soft, stay all day and doesn't smudge (I have only lids) , the only con is it's not really blendable, so if you want a softer look or use it as an eye shadow, it won't make it.. but over all i like this eyeliner!

Nice eyeliner, quite soft so there's no tugging, lasts quite long with minimal fading. Thankfully I haven't experienced much smudging, only if I go to bed without removing it, it will smudge a bit by morning, but that too looks like a lovely smokey eye. But during the day, it stays put for quite a while. I have black, purple and green in this. Black is of course the best, really dark and pigmented. The green and purple are nice colours, look great when I swatch them on my hand but don't really show up too well on my eyelids.

A great eyeliner but I wouldn't say that it lasts 16 hours. It's still prone to smudging but is not greasy.

I have one of these in "Violet Artiste", which I purchased for going to a party. I really like the colour and the way it compliments my hazel eyes, although it does come off after some time. I find that I have to re-apply it after around 2-3 hours. This isn't really a problem for me but I would prefer it if I didn't have to keep going to the bathroom to re-apply my eyeliner so often!!

This is my favorite eye pencil:
It's thick, but not greasy and doesn't smudge. I'm able to make a very fine line with it or to make a thicker sixties look, it all works well with this pencil.

I've recently starting using this eyeliner after ignoring it for ages. It didn't really beg to be used, as it's kind of boring looking. However, I gave it a go and I'm really pleased with the results. Mine is in the colour 'Vert Inspire' and I find that it compliments my hazel/green eyes. On my skintone it's more flattering and softer than black. Pigmentation is great, as is the texture. I can't remember exactly how much I paid for it, but it was definitely on clearance for under £2. It's a lovely every-day staple. Most days I'm bare faced except for this and a quick coat of mascara. I'd buy it again if I came across it for cheap.

My most important things in my make up bag. these don;t budge, are precise and have a very soft and smooth feel to them. love them. can't live without them. I'm an Indian vouching for this black khol... (i even stopped making my own khol for a while)

I found these pencils to be too hard for my skin. Plus colour melts away very quickly. Then I tried using eye primer (both Two Faced and UDPP) under, and nope, still melts. Shame considering I adore some of the colours.