I usually can say I really like a pencil eyeliner when just when I try the "black" shade. This is an exception!
I really like it and I will try other shades too! I have a plumy-brown shade, which looks soooo good on green eyes! It's soft, very pigmented and loooong lasting!
I have kinda sensitive eyes and didn't have any problems with this! Thumbs up!
I love this stuff. I'm usually totally loyal to Chanel eyeliner, but I bought this on a makeup emergency (came in wearing light makeup on staff photo day) - and am now hooked.
It goes on smooth and lasts for hours. I put it on at 7 in the morning, did a full day at work and a Pilates class at night, and it still looked good when I got home.
I have (this sounds gross) oily eyelids - and this stuff still doesn't budge. It's good for precision, too.
Overall - brilliant product. Love.
This liner applies easily onto eyelids, black is intense & matte. I would use this over smoky-grey, black eye shadow...but by late afternoon, it would smudge onto my lower eyelids. Not pretty. I spare this for short-term going outs, as it won't stay put for long.
Easy to apply- smooth
I think I am recommend these.
This is a quite good, easy to apply eyeliner. I'm using the black one and it's one of the best eyeliners I've used.It smudges a bit but It's good for the price.
pigmented, quite cheap, quite soft but not that soft, stay all day and doesn't smudge (I have only lids) , the only con is it's not really blendable, so if you want a softer look or use it as an eye shadow, it won't make it.. but over all i like this eyeliner!
Nice eyeliner, quite soft so there's no tugging, lasts quite long with minimal fading. Thankfully I haven't experienced much smudging, only if I go to bed without removing it, it will smudge a bit by morning, but that too looks like a lovely smokey eye. But during the day, it stays put for quite a while. I have black, purple and green in this. Black is of course the best, really dark and pigmented. The green and purple are nice colours, look great when I swatch them on my hand but don't really show up too well on my eyelids.
A great eyeliner but I wouldn't say that it lasts 16 hours. It's still prone to smudging but is not greasy.
I have one of these in "Violet Artiste", which I purchased for going to a party. I really like the colour and the way it compliments my hazel eyes, although it does come off after some time. I find that I have to re-apply it after around 2-3 hours. This isn't really a problem for me but I would prefer it if I didn't have to keep going to the bathroom to re-apply my eyeliner so often!!
This is my favorite eye pencil:
It's thick, but not greasy and doesn't smudge. I'm able to make a very fine line with it or to make a thicker sixties look, it all works well with this pencil.