OF the two palettes i found this one to be quite useless. The colors are too cool for me. The pink lippies are pigmented but just too hot pinkish for me. Blush barely shows up. The shadows are standard but for the green which is pretty but almost out of place. They are very pigmented but the glitter gets everywhere. I would not repurchase this set.
Again, like the A-Lister, I wish they would of put a mirror in this palette but either way, this is another FAB palette from Too Faced. The colors are not as neutral and usable as the A-Lister but still awesome. I am more in love with the lip glosses than anything else. Again, great packaging and great palette from Too Faced. *Update* This palette has been discontinued.
Overall this is a really good palette. You get an awesome selection of colours. The Icon is the more colourful of the two palettes that Too Faced has put out. All of the products are of high quality and the e/s blend really well. Like the other reviewer mentioned, the tools that come with it are absolutely useless. The one thing I did not like is that the descriptions on the box, sephora's website and Too Faced's website are very misleading. They make it sound like you are getting both colours from the eyeshadow duos and lip gloss duos they list, when in fact you are only getting one colour. Just make sure you realize this before ordering so that you are not dissapointed. Overall, it is a pretty good palette with a nice variety of colours. I would really like to try the other palette as well.