As far as quality is concerned, it deserves three stars, but because of its relatively low price I give it four stars. If you are looking for a basic brush set and a makeup case to go along with it, this is a good bargain. The quality of the brush is adequate. They do the job, but the blush brush and the lip brush are not very soft. The makeup case is compact and versatile. It's made of blinding red plastic exterior and grey polyester inner lining, but for the price, can't complaint. I've only used it for a couple of days, so I can't comment on its durability, but they haven't shed. I was looking for makeup brushes and a makeup case, without splurging, so this was a happy purchase for me.