Definitely a surprise for the price you pay. Tribeca Toast is a matte peachy tan, similar to Caboodles Hawaii only without shimmer and a littel darker. On me it's half blush, half subtle tan. I'm just not sure it's still around. Lately I've had a hard time finding it...
I thought that blush that cheap would be downright chalky... Not at all. I bought the peach and a light pink color and find that they go on very sheer and last all day on my oily skin.
I didn't expect to be so impressed with a $2 product, but this really is a great blush! Very soft, fine and translucent (reminded me of Neutrogena blushes), and I love the colour, a warm, peachy toast that gives a very natural glow. Goes on very smooth and blends with a stroke. I'll definitely be trying more of their blushes.