oh well.. very pretty rosy color, slighly pinkish but totally not my color :( too bad I love the texture and softness of this lip gel, it reminds me of applying KA's l/s! Anyway, I'd give it a 3.5 then.

This is actually a lip pencil, not a gloss or anything like that. I purchased one from another MUAer for a discount. I was a little nervous when I first saw it because the color did not look like 'rose' - it appeared to be a wild red! However, it applied as a gorgeous YLBB pinkish stain, without any brown undertones (as so many 'rose' shades have). Overall I am quite pleased, the pencil itself is very moisturizing. A word of caution, you do need to invest in a LARGE pencil sharpener to sharpen this, luckily I had one on hand from a PX Concealing Wand...just something to keep in mind. ;-) It is very easy to sharpen, though! I would repurchase this or try the other colors. :-)