Like the reviewer below, I have fair skin, but I'm far from porcelain-pale and this color doesn't really register on me. It just makes my eyelid look a bit washed out by neutralizing the pink tones in my skin, really not flattering. I gave it a two because it's matte and has a nice soft texture and also blends well, but it's not a great product. SK shadows fade on me and are not pigmented enough. I definitely recommend an eyeshadow base with them.
This color looks beautiful in the container, but just doesn't show up on me, which is odd because I'm blonde with blue eyes and pale/fair skin. The texture seemed good, so I gave it 2 rather than 1, but it was virtually like I was wearing nothing. I may try another shade as I liked the texture, but agree with another reviewer that it's annoying that matte and shimmer shades aren't described as such on the packaging.