I have tried many eyebrow products. Many. Powders look like a caterpillar on my face because I do have brow hair, but it's light and some hairs are even white now. Pencils are either too red or too yellow in the Ash or Taupe. So I went out on a limb here and bought this in dark brown. It has no red or yellow to it, and by using it with a light hand, I get a light brown brow, a true light brown that lasts all day. I love the hard pencil! Then I top it off with Mac brow gel to color the white hairs. It's a long pencil, but it's still pricey.
The Maybelline brow pencils are similar in hardness, which is nice, but they are way too reddish.
I gave it a 4 for packaging because I don't understand the brush on the end. I would prefer a spoolie, but I use it to dip in a white shadow to apply under my brow. I can't figure out what else it's for. It sure can't be for blending because it doesn't blend.
For other blondes who are looking for a light brown/taupe brow with no red/yellow, try the dark brown! It's a pleasant surprise.
This is the best eyebrow pencil I've tried so far, mostly because of the color. Raven-haired ladies rejoice! I have the shade Natural Black and it works with my black hair and brows. I've only used drugstore pencils and powders in the past and their shades usually have a lot of red undertones, so this product was a revelation! This fills in my brows very naturally.
I don't like having to sharpen the pencil, which wastes some product and is a slight inconvenience. I would love this Natural Black color as a mechanical pencil. I prefer the finer tip and the fact that you just twist the pencil to get more product. Anastasia Brow Wiz now comes in a black shade, so that may be next for me. I also don't use the brush side that often. I prefer to use a spoolie to brush out the pencil lines, but the brush works in a pinch.
While this product works pretty well for me, I'm a little at odds about the price. I have found drugstore brow pencils I like, but the shades are a little too warm toned and it takes more time to make them work for me. I'd happily go back to Maybelline Define-a-Brow if they'd make a shade like this. Until then..
This is my HG eyebrow pencil. As other reviewers have mentioned, this is great for Asian eyebrows. I've been using Natural Black for a good 5 years now, and don't ever plan on trying a new eyebrow pencil since this one has been so dear to me. This is a product that I fear will one day be discontinued. I can't say that about most products out there.
It goes on just right; not too creamy and opaque like other eyebrow pencils I've tried. It has great staying power, and blends seamlessly with my natural eyebrow color.
This eyebrow brush was fine, but nothing special. I should note that I am not picky about eyebrow pencils and have used both department and drugstore pencils without seeing significant difference in either.
A number of reviewers said this worked well with "Asian eyebrows," which at first, I was not sure what they meant specifically (even though I am also Asian). However, thinking about it, I think they mean that this eyebrow pencil contains no red undertones (a problem with a lot of eyebrow pencils) and works well with those who have neutral or yellow undertones on their skin. Yet, I feel this pencil would work on a variety of skintones, so don't be deterred if you aren't Asian.
I like this eyebrow pencil, especially because it gives a soft, natural, and feminine look. However, I didn't think it was much value for the cost. Perhaps I was using it wrong, but I ran out of it in a couple of months, and just couldn't justify $20 every other month just for brows.
I bought this in Natural Black, which is more of a darkish cool gray colour.
I debated getting this forever, because really, it's 30 bucks for a grey pencil. I'm not disappointed at all that I did though! The colour is amazing for Asians, and it really does look very natural. The brush is also quite good at blending in the pencil without lifting too much colour. The pencil is soft, but not so creamy that you go through it super fast. I've used mine for half year every single day, and there's still quite a stick left. I don't need to sharpen it too much either, since it works well with a dull point. That means I don't waste too much product, hurray!
I just wish it was a bit cheaper, but it's really quite worth the money.
I'm so glad I listened to all the great reviews on here and from youtube and purchased this gem.
I have the usual sparse Asian eyebrows. I have this in natural black - the colour is more gray so I was a little skeptical when I first opened it but when I applied, it looked very natural and not too "made up". It's perfect for my brown-black hair.
I think this has replaced the Lioele auto eyebrow as my HG eyebrow product. Although I really like the Lioele one, this looks more natural and I have a feeling it will last a lot longer. More pricey, but also more readily available for purchase.
This is my HG eyebrow product. I fill in my sparse Asian eyebrows every single day. If I was only allowed one makeup item for the rest of my life, it would be an eyebrow product. I love this pencil because it's not creamy, I don't like creamy pencils for my brows. Also, the color I use, Natural Black (which is actually more of a dark gray color), is perfect for my dark brown/black hair. I like the other end of the pencil that has a brush, it blends out any harsh lines. This pencil is not incredibly long-wearing, but lasts decently through a work day.
When I first bought it I thought it was a bit pricey but it's lasted me so long that I've realized it's definitely worth it. I've been using the same pencil for almost a year and have yet the need to buy a new one. I also love the little angle brush it comes with, its perfect for brushing the product into your brows for a natural look. Will buy this again when I need to.
I loved the shu uemera pencil, but I was sad that the line was taken out from the US and I didn't like buying online because of the high shipping fee so I decided to go buy the Shiseido one since it was Japanese also . The shiseido one is morepricey than the shu uemera which is actually better. The shu uemera was 4g for 22 dollars but the shiseido was 20 for 1.1g. The shu uemra was made in japan so it worked really well, natural, and reasonably priced, but the other day when I looked at the shiseido pencil I got at MACY'S, it said made in CHINA. Okay, for the biggest cosmetic Japanese based company, its products shouldn't be made in China. I don't have anything against China, just how they make their products and regulations, plus Chinese products are supposed to be dirt cheap, but it turned out pricier than the one made in Japan. Coastal scents and ELF are made in China, and they're really inexpensive, but I don't like them because I'm always iffy about poisoning that could cause skin cancer from Chinese products, and I'm really disappointed in Shiseido this time. Just going to have to find a better eyebrow pencil.
On the plus side, the angled brush isn't super stiff, but it's not the best, and it's only good for blending for the products. The color payoff is pretty good, but you have to be careful or you'll have super thick eyebrows, Sharpied like, but I'm honestly not going to repurchase. Too overpriced and not that great of a product. If it was made in Japan, then it would've been a different story.
I just purchased my second in deep brown about a month ago. I must say i LOVE this pencil! its absolutely perfect! It's easy to use... you can go for a natural looks or layer for a more intense look super easily! I absolutely love it... I bought it in deep brown and will keep buying it as long as they make it!