I have to agree with the previous reviewer. This is just dreadful. It is so thick and sticky that it has to be quite literally pulled across the lips with your fingertips. The colour is pure frost with no discernible pink - absolutely unwearable. Very disappointing.

I had never tried Kiehl's lip products before and wanted to give their colored l/g a shot, since I'm a sucker for any new l/g. Anyways, I decided to try their Lip Paint in Pink Shine--a light pink shade that I figured I couldn't go wrong with. Boy was I wrong. Besides smelling absolutely horrible, the stuff went on frost white, NOT pink at all! Maybe it's because my lips are rather pigmented, but it was ghastly. Plus the stuff is like paint...VERY thick and sticky, but not in a good way. It took me forever to get the stuff off, even with soap and water. A definite thumbs down on this product.