I really like this eyeliner, but they no longer sell it at sephora. i wear contacts and this is really gentle and i can line my bottom lid with it.
This is an okay liner. Definitely not the smoothest or long lasting. I have this in licorice, which is supposed to be black, but to be real, this isn't very black at all. The silver cap keeps coming off, which is a real annoyance. This isn't worth 14 bucks, certainly not for just plain 'black'. Even drugstores have waay better black pencil liners than this.