I just got this in shade #17 (Chocolate) and am very happy. It's a dark shimmery chocolate brown and gives a very dramatic look. I'm a PPP and I need to blot this or else, it's just too much. And since I got this on sale at Sephora for $5, I can't complain =) I'm glad to have found a Stila knockoff for cheap and I'm also glad that it's not so sheer like others out there. These definitely give you color.