This is my all time favorite BBW foody scents. It's a sweet buttery doughy cream that has absolutely no underlying *off* smell to it, that many other lotions can have. I wish they would bring this back and am surprised they havent. Much, much better than Vanilla Bean Noel IMO, which they did bring back. The other reviewer gave it two lippies because she doesn't want to smell like butter cookies...well, look at it as another 100 percent because that's what it's SUPPOSED to smell like and there's no surprise in the name.

LOVED this lotion when they still made it. Perfect buttery warm scent.

I am obsessed with this lotion!! I don't have access to it in Australia - but I have had it sent to me via my lovely enabler and I am seriously hooked!! It smells simply divine! Just like cookies, vanilla - sugar, spice and all things nice!!
I cannot say enough good things about this lotion! A MUSt for those that love foody scents.
It goes well with CSP Vanille, Vanille Abricot and AdC.

Why they made this scent limited edition while adding the likes of Creamy Coconut to their permanent collection baffles me. This is truly their best scent ever. It is a warm sweet buttery vanilla scent that is almost edible. I love everything about it from the scent to the adorable packaging. I hope they do one day bring it back as I know it will fly off the shelves.

Butter Cookie smells as though you rolled around in a fresh batch of.. well, butter cookies! It's a great, playful, yummy scent. I find it a little too sweet for everyday use, but I do like it as a hand lotion. The bottle is ultra-cute, too. Hope they bring this one back!

OMG! I love this scent. Smells exactly like a butter cookie. It's the yummiest smell! I really hope they bring this back during the holiday season again, and i will definitely stock up if they do.

Why oh why did they discontinue this? I love it! I have like 6 bottles of it and I'll be so sad the day they are all gone. What a wonderful butter cream scent. The lotion itself is thicker than their regular lotion but not as thick as the body creams. The scent is heaven!!!! If you like sweet foody scents, this is it!

One of the best discontinued lotions and scents that Bath and Body Works had out last fall and winter! Smells exactly like the Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie or Buttercream candles! Packaged in a little maple syrup looking container, it was a wonderful scent to layer with the matching shower gel! Not a great thing for dieters to wear, LOL! Wish they would bring this scent back!