This product is really bad. I always like Maybelline's mascaras, that's why I thought maybe I should give its eye make up remover a try. It turns out this product is a total waste! I use it only twice and it goes to my trash can---Extremetly greasy and it removes nothing except my eye lash!

yuck! this is nasty eh.... super greasy, hardly removed my lashfinity! made my vision blurry and it burned my eyes.....aaahhhhhhh!!!!!

Mine is called Expert Eyes Moisturizing Eye makeup remover. It has a pink top and is for waterproof mascara also, as opposed to the 100% oil free with the blue top. I don't know WHAT I was thinking getting this - yes I do, I was broke and it was on sale. I thought I read it - but yuck - the FIRST ingredient is Mineral Oil. This product thankfully took off my eyemakeup well, and did make my lashes feel soft - but my lids feel SOO super greasy! I even rubbed a dry washcloth over it all when I was done, and the greasy is still lightly there! Though this may be appealing for someone, it is not for me.

I've always used Pond's Cold Cream to remove all my makeup and it's done a good job of it. Well.... I thought I'd buy my first eye makeup remover to see if I could have an easier time taking off my waterproof mascaras. I got this one because it says it removes ALL waterproof eye makeup and when I did try it it didn't remove any of my waterproof mascara. None of it came off. This sucks soo bad!!!!!!