I haven't tried the lipstick with the same name, but I do like this lip pencil. On me, it goes on a medium rose color. I sometimes wear it by lining and filling my lips and topping it (and help spread it) with a non-glossy clear lip gloss (such as Maybelline Wet Shine in Crystal Clear or Blistex Silk & Shine). This is definitely a "my lips but better" shade in my case. This color works as a liner for a variety of lip colors too.