I bought this after finding liquid eyeliners frustrating and messy, and was impressed with the packaging and softness of the pencil in store. Unfortunately though this product is a disaster! Even with a light hand it smears everywhere, and after only a couple of hours it's melted off my eyes onto my cheeks (and it's not even warm here right now!). It has no staying power at all. I wouldn't touch this again, there are much better products out there.