This was my first HOG Pumpkin Butter. Depravity is a heavily perfumed, but if you like the scent, which lingers, it's great. I would repurchase this scent, especially because my boyfriend LOVED it.
All the Pumpkin Butters are light creams with Pumpkin Seed Oil and Shea Butter being the most prolific ingredients after water. The consistency is thicker than lotion but thinner than most conventional body butters, including my HG for super dry skin, Cetaphil's Moisturizing Cream Tub. The 2oz tubs are a great way to try a lot of different scents without making a huge commitment in terms of $ or products, and the size is perfect for travel. I got Depravity in a large tub, but if I were to purchase again I'd probably get the smaller size, just so I could try more scents without getting overloaded with product.
I will continuing purchasing Haus of Gloi Pumpkin Butters. They keep adding new scents, and have LE products each season which keeps things interesting. The gothic aesthetic of the brand is also really nice and HOG makes for a great gift.