I really like this "eyeshadow pencil". I use this creamy white stick shadow as a white eyeliner on my lower lashline. I would say that it is a little thicker than I would like it to be, because it often gets on my lower lashes, but it is advertised as an eyeshadow and not an eyeliner so I can't complain much. This product deserves 4 stars because it does what it says...it definitely lasts 12 hours, unlike a lot of white eyeshadows/liners I apply to my lower lashline. Also, the product is very creamy and really white, which I love... & The price is so good!! Jordana is one of the better low-priced drugstore makeup brands.