Holy c**p, this is by far the worst eyeliner I have ever bought. To my chagrin also the most expensive ( 20£ for a pencil that needs sharpening). First of all, it's really dry. I had to rub it on so hard my skin felt sore. It goes on blotchy and sets immediately- no time to smudge it. In my despair I tried to soften it by warming it up with a lighter...it just melted briefly and turned to stone again. Another con: It smells really bad...cheap and plasticy. Has no one at OG tried this product before throwing it on the market???