This is like my 4th attempt at trying colored mascara and im just wasting my money. I have black lashes and the pink makes my lashes look grey and just down right ridiculous. It takes so much going over for any color to be shown. Ive tried Maybelline and other brands and its just not working for me. I don't think colored mascara is made for black lashes. I can see more of a color pop on blonde lashes. If you have black lashes, don't waste your money on any colored mascara for that matter. Its not this brand, its all of them! But if you do want to give it a try, theres nothing Wet n Wild cant give you that other brands can and I do get the best application out of this brand..