I was previously using the Bioderma Sensibio H2O for removing both my face make-up and eye make-up. While it did remove eye make-up, it required a lot of rubbing, and I wanted something gentler on the eyes, that would wipe my waterproof mascara and eyeliner easier.
I decided to first try the cheap options at the drugstore, and this one seemed like a good option, especially because I had heard good things about dual eye make-up removers.
It took 2 wipes with 1 cotton pad to take off my waterproof mascara and eyeliner. One for taking off the largest part, and one for cleaning up. I followed the instructions and let it soak into my eyelashes for 10 seconds, and it worked perfectly. I didn't need to rub or press too hard, and it felt both gentle and effective. It also did not leave an oily film on my eyelids and my eyelashes felt nice and soft after application.