This eyeliner is 98% perfect. Very pigmented, easy to use, glides nicely, and stays put...for about a few hours. The reason I gave this 4 lippies is because I can put this eyeliner on around 11am, and by 4pm it strangely gets sticky, sticks to my upper lid and it smudges. I haven't experienced this with any other liner, from liquid to gel. So if I know I'm going out at night, I have to take my eye makeup off and do it all over again. So embarrassing in public though :( I would still highly recommend though, it may just be my eyes. Great eyeliner.
At first I really liked this product and for the first two weeks it was a HG for me, but then the brush tip started splitting. I thought I had a faulty one so I contacted customer service and they were super helpful. They sent me two brand new ones and I sent the old one back to their facility. After around a month of using my second Jesse's girl liquid eyeliner, I noticed the brush started to split again and eventually it looked like a paint brush by the time I used it up.
Longevity wise, the liquid liner lasted me about 3 months, maybe 1 month of maximum eyeliner wear with not problems with the brush tip splitting. I wore this everyday by the way and used very little pressure when applying this on my lids. Maybe I got two faulty ones. I just started on my third tube of jesse's liquid liner so we'll see how this one goes.
The formula, however, I love!! Waterproof, smudge proof and pigmented all in one! It would be my perfect eyeliner if the tip just did not split. :/ I have high hopes for this third one, the splitting of the brush is really the biggest downer I have with this eyeliner which is why I gave it 3 stars over all.
Got this from my Sep. Ipsy bag-- New favorite liquid eyeliner!
The tip is like a really thin brush, and it makes it really easy to apply a perfect line, or wing. It is extremely long lasting and won't smudge away at all. So great for all day wear!
Received this in my ipsy bag this month. By far my new favorite eyeliner. I absolutely love it. Very pigmented and has great staying power. Also, easily glides on for fool proof application. Will 100% continue using :)
Oh my goodness, I LOVE THIS!!! The perfect brush - not a felt tip - for the thinnest line ever! I can apply this effortlessly every morning - no early morning makeup drama - and it lasts all day. When I want a stronger look I take a slanted brush and thicken the line with any shade of dark eyeshadow. This thing is fabulous!!!
I am a Stila eyeliner devotee. I like long lasting liner. This is not bad for the money. If I am careful I get about 6 hours. I think it's worth a try. Not fantastic. But the brush is great and it's close to being a great long wearing liner.
FAVORITE! This replaced my favorite dolly wink eyeliner. Fantastic thin brush. Liner goes on smooth and dark. Lasts me all day. Doesn't break the bank. YAY.
This eyeliner has a good brush and its easy to apply but its smudges on me I don't know why I don't have oily eyelids and it also fades on me after an hour of wearing it.
This is the only liquid eyeliner that doesn't smudge on me, stays put all day. I have a watery eyes because of my eye defect, a very fine application and works well with cat eye look. I can't live without this eyeliner. I've tried everything in the drugstore but this one is my HG. For the price of $7 can't beat that. I already purchase some backups!