I love this product. I actually love the smell and the tingly feeling. It's great for blending too. Only reason I wouldn't give it a 5 is because it doesn't stay on all that long. I can't find it anywhere though (the lipgloss I have is very old). Did they stop making it?

Pretty color and made my lips feel moisturized, but the scent was too much. No wonder they call it "refreshing." I guess I learned my lesson! I will not buy again because the scent was like toothpaste.

This shade is a light coral-peach, no shimmer, looks very shiny on. I got this because i heard that Alchemy's lip glosses were minty but was disappointed with the scent. Smelled like old, stale mint to me. I felt a tinge of menthol. Was disappointed at the tiny amount of product you get for $17. I can't think of another high end brand that makes their l/g tubes smaller than this one (even Delux Beauty l/g tubes are bigger!)
Update: Saw them at Sephora, they have increased the size of these tubes, but still would not purchase this again.