This was a good product for the most part. If you like making a thick line then you will love this! It had pretty good color payoff (I have seen better) BUT this eyeliner dried out after about 3 months. That really disappointed me. I will not be repurchasing after that.
NOTE: I purchased this at CVS with several coupons and ended up getting two for $9.36 (regularly $7.39 each) so that's why it has a 2 for cost!
I really like this chubby pen! Great color payoff, easy-peasy application (even for a super non steady hand like me), great for creating dramatic cat eye or winged looks. I have SUPER oily eyelids and the stuff didn't BUDGE. And I'm a chronic eye rubber (contacts, allergies, habit)... No raccoons or pandas emerged :-)
Very happy with the success and pay off for buying this product on a whim! LOVED the Milani Infinite Liquid Liner but alas, I suck at life when it comes to using that blasted brush effectively and getting the line as thin as I want. Plus my janky eye lashes are forever getting liner on them with that wand/brush so the Eye Tech BOLD has been my hero :-)
I'll have to test it's wear in the shower (before I go traipsing out in the rain/humidity!)