I generally really like Rimmel products but this eyeliner is a complete failure. Difficult to sharpen and not have the point break, the stuff smudges all over and is impossible to not get all over your hands, and it is by no means waterproof. If it wasn't so cheap i'd be more upset, but I definitely will not purchase again!
My eyelids are oily and in some cases, I am prone to crying for whatever reason. However, using this eyeliner, I don't have to worry about such things at all. I have this in Kohl and I feel like it doesn't smudge throughout the day which is definitely a +1 because I have such oily lids.
The eyeliner glides very smoothly onto your lids and is satisfyingly pigmented. I like to use this more for my water lines and tight-lining.
My only concern is that I feel like the product itself doesn't last that long because of it's creamy consistency and I keep having to sharpen the pencil. Additionally, the cap tends to come off easily which is kind of annoying. Although, both problems might be just me.
To anyone who'd like a inexpensive alternative against your usual $20 eyeliner purchases (I honestly don't understand why people would splurge on eyeliner pencil in the first place), I definitely recommend this Rimmel liner.
I have been looking and looking for a great waterproof eyeliner at the drugstore and I still haven't found one after almost a whole year of searching. I don't have watery eyes or oily eyelids, but for some reason eyeliners always run on me. I decided to get this eyeliner after hearing such great things about it. I tested it for about a week and it never lasted and always smudged and ran down my face. It's not waterproof and it doesn't last long. I returned it and am glad that I did. Won't be repurchasing or even reconsidering
I use the Nude and the Taupe in this line...and while the Taupe smudges a bit I wasn't sure if it was me imagining it with the Taupe or if it was really happening. So I bought the black to try, yup, they smudge. I have very dark under eye circles, so smudging black liner just makes me look like I have an addiction or health issues. I was going to give it 1 lippie because they should not be smudging, I don't even have oily lids! But, it does go on smooth and creamy. So I will at least give it a two. Now if for some reason, smudging is ok with you, then it is a lovely product.
problems with eyeliner blurring your contacts? TRY THIS :D! for the longest time I was using milani's eyeliner but I guess the formula is just too soft where it would smudge onto my contacts throughout the day. This was obviously a problem since I couldn't see jack $#!t through blurry contacts. Such a pain. I finally took a risk with this eyeliner and I'm not looking back! It's even MORE affordable than the milani one and most importantly - NO BLURRY CONTACTS :D! the one down side I can see with this item is that you have to sharpen it. if they could finally crank out a swivel pencil version like milani had then I'd love it even more but I don't mind too much. inexpensive, pigmentation is awesome and lasts about 5-6 hours before looking a tad faded. Reapplying isn't a big deal for me and I find that it rarely smudges/travels under my eyes compared to the milani one which I had to constantly check to my sure it didn't run throughout the day.
Overall, one of the better pencil eyeliners in the drugstore, that's for sure. I still got a fair amount of smudging after a few hours, which was disappointing, and I didn't find that it stayed in my waterline very well. However, it's easy to use, is very pigmented, and is much easier to use (and does smudge less) than other drugstore pencil eyeliners, so I will probably buy again when I run out (that will be a long time from now though, so who knows, maybe something better will be out by then. I am by no means attached to this product).
Very black eyeliner, but does smudge after a couple hours. Because of that, I would not buy it again.
This is one of the best eyeliners. It's super easy to apply. It glides on smoothly. It's cheap. Under $5. It's creamy. Lasts for hours. Pigmentation is great. It does smudge after a couple of hours though. But nothing too intense like running mascara.
waterproof? f'n kidding me right??? styli-style, revlon colorstay...THOSE ARE WATERPROOF! yes this eyeliner is creamy, yes it is super black, but after 1 1\2 hours i looked as if i just cried my eyes out! it is so awful....i cannot believe rimmel had the balls to call this waterproof. if you want smudgy eyes....or looked like you just got back from a crack house, get this eyeliner...otherwise save your 6 dollars and stick with revlon colorstay. it isnt the creamiest, but you wont look as if you have partied for 24 hours.... avoid this...U WERE WARNED.
I love this eyeliner! It's cheap - in Australia it retails for 10$ In stores. But on sale or on asos it is about $7. It's incredibly creamy, which is good but sometimes makes it hard to work with. In that, you have to be careful that you don't put too much on. But that is the product's only "downfall" I would say. It's very long wearing. It definitely 'sets' and doesn't budge. Although I will always set it with a black eyeshadow. I was bad one night and slept in my makeup, the eyeliner was still on my waterline when I woke up! Love love love this eyeliner. I have already bought a back up :P