I find this eyeliner creamy and easy to apply. It doesn't smudge on my eyelids but after about two hours it smudges but not drastically. I'm not disappointed but I won't buy another one as the lasting power is not what I expected.
This is probably the blackest eyeliner I've ever used. It is almost too black for me and I don't seem to reach for it all the time. I wish Rimmel would make a charcoal gray in this formula -- that would be my happy medium. Nevertheless, this is a stay put formula. I usually just tightline with this and even after I take my eye makeup off, there usually is still some remnant remaining in my lash line. I'm actually okay with that because it gives the look that my lashes are fuller! But yes, this is a great product. I'm surprised at its lasting wear and the pigment of the liner.
Wow, I'm definitely impressed with this liner. I tried the Rimmel Scandaleyez eyeshadow pencil in Blackmail and that was disappointing, so I wasn't expecting much. This is a deep, rich black that went on smoothly, and set to a smudge-proof line. I picked this up at CVS for 40% off. Even if it's not on sale, it's a good deal. I think the regular price was $4.99.
I actually really like this eyeliner! It's a very creamy, not unlike the Urban Decay 24/7 liners, which I love but do not have the budget for. Usually when I use this, it goes along my upper lashline and then I smudge it out with some black eyeshadow for a really smokey look. I've never used it on the waterline though, so I'm not a good judge on that kind of staying power.
But compared to all the other drugstore eyeliners, I would definitely say this one is my favorite and I will be repurchasing it when it runs out :)
I really like this product. It's probably one of the best drugstore eyeliners right now. the pigmentation is great, it's very creamy. You can put it on without tugging your eyelids.And it stays there for a while. it's a win
I bought this liner for days when I wear liner on my waterline.. needed something that stays and it did it's job! I've tried wearing it when I line my eye lid, gives a amazing dark look but does tend to smudge some...
I really don't like pencil eyeliners because I find it hard to create a cat eye with them, and sharpening them is a pain. However, on my "lazy days" where I just want to wear eyeliner and mascara, I use this pencil. All the (drugstore) pencil liners I've tried before were so stiff and I would have to almost stab my eye to get the pigment to show up on my lids. This pencil is really creamy and goes on well, which is great for people who wear contacts like me. Having to jab my lid with a pencil that isn't creamy hurts my contacts and eyes. I find that this pencil smudges quite a bit since it's so soft, but setting it with some matte black shadow helps it a bit. If you prefer a smokier look, or a non-cat eye liner look, then this liner is great for you!
Love this eyeliner, the best one I've tried soo far! The packaging is standard i wouldve personally preferred if it was a twist up (makes my life easier from having to sharpen it) but other then that excellent pencil. Great pigmentation!
Gives a defined line or you can build up to a thicker liner. Stays all day and looks really black! Great cheap purchase.
This eyeliner is amazing! I have very oily skin so I need an eyeliner with great staying power. The consistency of this liner is very creamy and highly pigmented. It lasts for hours and hours!! I can wear this for more than 12 hours and it won't budge. It does smudge a little bit, but only a tad bit. Even when it smudges other people can barely notice and it looks quite nice actually. This is definitely my to go liner, and for the price, this product is perfect.