This is a good eyeliner for lining the eyes, a little less good for the waterline as it smudge there. But on upper and lower lash line it is decently long lasting. As far as the sharpening problem, people you need a good heavy duty makeup pencil sharpener and you won't have a problem...actually even the 1 dollar sharpener from Sally's does the job. Green Ivy is truly a beautiful color, but overall they are all nice with excellent color payoff.
So many pretty colors. They look so great on me too, but...is there anyone out there who knows how to sharpen this?? Or what to use? Once the point is gone, I can't sharpen any of the four I bought, no matter what sharpener I use. Very frustrating.
Picked this up when Ulta had BOGO 50%, so glad I didn't spend full price as this eyeliner is really, really bad! The color is nice and very opaque but it doesn't seem to dry down. After application the product just sits and never seems to dry down but does move around and smudge/transfer all over. This has to be one of the messiest products I have ever had the misfortune of using.
I just tried this eyeliner in the purple shade, and wow! Very impressed. Once it's on your upper lash line it does not smear or transfer to the crease of your eyelid at all. This stayed in place all day at work and then some! I had to use a q-tip after I applied it because a teensy bit got on my bottom lashes, but after I cleaned up the area, nothing smeared/ smudged all day and I work in a hot retail store all day. I have got to try these in every color. Very lovely texture, and pigment. Yay
Its a good product , very precise but i found that 2true in superdrug does a similar liner for half the price
Love it love it so soft does it wear all day no but idc its good enough
This eyeliner is smooth but smudges everywhere. Immediately. So disappointing that I'm just going to throw it away!
This is soft and smooth and a true black but oh my, the smudging. I just looked in the mirror and it's everywhere. I was hoping for a cheaper alternative to my Make Up Forever eyeliner but this is not it. It's actually too soft. I have to sharpen it every time I use it which is a massive pain
I wanted to like this but just didn't. It was very easy to apply but melted and smudged all over my eyes as the day went on, and not in a good way. Also, the gold band looks pretty but made it difficult to sharpen. Will never repurchase this. Such a mess
This is the WORST, eyeliner I have ever bought! Every fifteen minutes I had to wipe the outside corner of my eye. I had high hopes but they were quickly squashed.