While I loved the colors (I bought the Chocolate and the Deep Purple), the formula wasn't right for me. It glided on easily; however, if you're not quick, it'll start to dry and can get tricky. Also after 3 or 4 hours, it started "chipping" off (kind of like paint). I ended up returning both to Ulta.
I did love the color - it was very saturated and pretty, but I'll stick with Maybelline's Eye Tattoo; love that stuff!
I have only just bought this and used it with an eyeliner brush to line my upper lids. Worked absolutely beautifully for that. I took the cream off of the doe foot with a MAC liner brush and lined above my NYX Super Fat Liner (which I also love) and it was opaque in one stroke and easy to apply. Can't comment on the staying power as I only wore it for a few hours in the evening.