It's the only nude liner I've tried, and it's pretty good. It works with my skin tone, but if you're darker, it may disappoint because it can still look white, as it does on me. As for longevity, when I get home after 6 hours, I can faintly see it on my waterline. I wouldn't call it waterproof. It was fairly cheap in the US but I haven't seen it in Canada.

finally! an affordable, creamy nude liner! this is the best liner for my waterline from the drugstore. it doesn't last all day but it's really creamy and super great for brightening

I use it as a brow highlighter and love it. The staying power is outstanding.

i do like this pencil its creamy great at brightening but has no lasting power on the waterline i get about 1-2 hours before its completely gone which sucks because i dont reapply makeup throughout the day it glides on great just no staying power will not be buying again

Love this. Great texture that glides on easily and lasts on my waterline fairly decent for several hours!

Even though I have the Stila kajal in Topaz, I thought I give this one a try since it's cheaper and heard last longer on the waterline. This stayed on my waterline for 8 hrs with a eye primer. ! I haven't worn Topaz in a while but I don't remember staying on my waterline for this long. I have also purchased Rimmel Scandaleyes in blk and taupe, truly amazing bargains!

Love this! I bought if from Target yesterday for $5. It's a great dupe of Tarte's nude waterline eyeliner. It stays on for hours and it gives the illusion of "bigger eyes" which I love. I am NC15 at Mac (pale with warm undertones) and I find that this is close to my skin colour which I really like. I definitely recommend it over Tarte or Stila!

I was looking for a nude eyeliner since white can sometimes be too harsh. I didn't want to spend so much money getting the Stila one so i was hoping they had a d/s one. I was super exciting when i found out that Rimmel had one and rushed to Walmart ASAP. It's a kajal pencil so it's soft and creamy and also waterproof (apparently). I love the color of this and how it so pigmented. I use this to line my waterline. it lasts a pretty long time and makes my eyes look bigger and brighter. I also got this in 003 (?) Brown :) will definitely be going back to buy backups!

wore this on one eye and nars bonaparte on the other. this one lasted longer and was more natural looking. ref: NC40/42, yellow undertoned skin. its not as BRIGHT as nars but i dont mind, it cancels out the redness and thats all i need! not an exact dupe but for the price? $3.00 vs $24.50? CANT BEAT IT! the nars was just too alien looking on my inner rim and had no lasting power-returned to sephora. good stuff and will look into buying their black color to substitute my Chanel, MAC & UD liners :) would get 5 stars if it was just a tad bit brighter (perfect shade for day wear but i would like a bit more pop for night) but not a big deal. Put it on at 7:30 am this morning and its noon, mostly still intact! continued >>

Just got this eyeliner today, and I can say the wear time is about 2-3 hours on the waterline. This is an exact dupe for the Stila kajal eyeliner in Topaz (I own both)! And like a quarter of the price! It definitely gives you that bright eyed look and is well worth the money! I totally recommend this product, but be aware that you will have to reapply after about 3 hours.