These have pretty copper and dark bronze pencils, but they are softer than the classic PF eyeliners, which wear much better on my oily lids. Still not a bad buy--I'll try them as a smudgy shadow too.
There is apparently a nude and warm nudes version of this product. Warm nudes includes three pencils in copper, bronze and black. The actual formula of the pencils is ok. They don't smear and seem to wear well which is nice. I do wish they went on and blended just a tad smoother (my skin was doing that wrinkly pulling thing as I applied) and that the point was a bit broader. I like the packaging. They are capped which keeps them clean and from getting broken. The copper and bronze are both really pretty and combining all three pencils the way pictured on the back gave my eyes a really nice look. CVS often has really good sales for this brand so I paid $7 something which is really good for three pencils. EDIT knocked off a lippie because these pencils actually tend to smudge and migrate throughout day