I stumbled upon these liners in Sephora one day while looking for a dupe for an Urban Decay color. I own three of these liners and have been very happy with all of them. My most recent purchase is the Flashy Black Purple color. If you are looking for a great dupe for Urban Decay Rockstar- look no further! This liner is an almost spot on dupe for Rockstar, perhaps just a smidge redder but just a smidge. It has the identical sheen as Rockstar. It is creamy and goes on smoothly like the UD liners, it's smudgeable for the first 20 seconds or so and then sets up and stays put! The best part is that these liners sell for $8. Great quality liners for a lot less than Urban Decay.