I'd like to start by saying that I have no idea what the contact lens reviewer is on about - I wear soft contact lenses and circle lenses, and have never had an issue with this eyeliner. Ever. Even when it's on my waterline.
Anyway, the staying power of this liner is commendable. It goes on smoothly and has a bold finish without you having to go over it more than once. Definitely going to pick up some more colors to try. The only gripe I do have is that the tube doesn't really like to twist....
This product is not worth the hype. I wear soft contact lenses. I know my fellow contact lens wearers will agree with me that the protein build-up you get can be quite annoying. Well, I think that this liner has some kind of oil in it. The eyeliner got on my contact lenses and I got the protein build-up with it the first day I wore the eyeliner. I had to throw the lenses away. Won't be using this anymore or recommending it to anyone.
Me gusta el acabado que da, además de ser muy suaves.
This is the 2nd eyeliner I've purchased. There seems to be a problem getting the stick to turn so the liner can emerge. The 2nd time this has happened. It's good, color nice, and staying power but not enough to not be able to use the product.
Love this drugstore eyeliner! The staying power is amazing! I have super watery eyes and even my Urban Decay 24/7 liner didn't hold up. The liner is also very creamy so it goes on really smooth. With all this being said I sadly can't use this product...my eyes seem to hate this liner and I hate them(my eyes) for hating it! They get really red, itchy, and burn when I put it on. I really hate that cause I feel this is probably the best liner out there....
HG eyeliner. Goes on super smooth, i've tryed other drugstore brands but always come back to this one. I repurchase all the time!
I can't believe this eyeliner doesn't have more reviews than this! I absolutely love it! I tested it out today in 95 degree heat and it DID NOT smudge and stayed on all day! Girls, go get you some! I think this will be my HG! I'm getting more asap!
This is the longest lasting eyeliner out there. I did a test comparing this to MAC, UD and other drugstore eyeliners while this was not the creamiest it was the longest lasting, the most smudge proof eyeliner. I prefer the Milani or NYX because they are creamier but if for some reason I wasn't able to find it this would be by next choice over MAC and UD.
My favorite drugstore eyeliner!
Pros: Creamy, highly pigmented, long lasting as of pigmentation and wear, easy and quick to apply. The cap fits on the bottom of the pencil, a small yet beneficial pro. It gives the look of a gel liner but with the ease of a pencil. These contain a small amount of sparkle, wish they had a matte or satin option but the sparkle is not that noticeable to be a turn off.
I love this eyeliner!! I own the black, blue and purple one. These liners are ridiculously creamy yet they last so long on the waterline. I use the black one to tightline and the colored ones if I want a pop of color in my eye makeup. Love that it's an automatic pencil; im lazy like that. Little product comes out at a time when you twist the pencil. Def would repurchase!
I use the black one to tight line. I've come to the conclusion that I don't like using this eyeliner for that purpose. This product is really creamy and it does take a while to set. So I have to make sure I don't blink too hard or else the liner will transfer to my waterline.