Basically, this gave a really natural look and it smudges quite badly. I saw like 2 fibers on the brush but the formula was too dry for the fibers to attach to my lashes. The extreme black color wasn't that black. It held a curl decently. The brush was a bit awkward. I felt like each individual bristle was too fat to get in between my lashes. Rimmel's had much better mascaras before.

I love this mascara,it separates my lashes really well , even better than the Maybelline Falsies and it doesn't clump on me.
HOWEVER, it does smudge and come off to my lower lash line after a few hours.

I had heard a good review about this (brush and formula were great), so I thought I would give it a try. It is terrible. Dry, dry, dry. The brush is a great design, I am going to try and jab it into a different tube of mascara that I do like.

Okay firstly the brush works amazing in separating and leaving no clumps. Unfortunately the formula is so dry and thin it feels like it's scraping my eyelashes. If they had this brush with the orange scandal eyes we would have a great mascara. Would not recommend

I am very into trying different mascaras. I figured if try this one because I was curious about the brush. I think the top ball portion should be a tad smaller. But honestly it wouldn't matter all that much unless they completely remake the formula. I. Ended up using it 3 times and throwing it away. It dried quick is clumpy and flakes onto my skin. Can't get any worse than that really.

I really need to stop getting suckered in by commercials lol. I got this bc I thought it would give the 'false' lash effect especially with the "so-called" lengthening fibres. This did nothing. The formula was dry and dry....and oh, did I mention.... DRY?! The result was hard brittle spider looking lashes!! GROSS. Also during the day... a fibre or 2 from the mascara fell into my eyes and caused it to keep watering annoyingly. It also ruined all the under eye makeup I had on! I will stick to the L'oreal Voluminous mascara and never stray away again!!

The commercials convinced me to buy this mascara along with the Rimmel Flex one as well ( I like to use lengthening and volumizing mascaras together to get both results) and I must say that this stuff is pretty good. It gave me great length, lasted for a long time, didn't flake, etc. I still love my Maybelline mascara way better than this one it gives me better results so the only way that I would buy this product again, is if Maybelline isn't available.

Buy this for the wand, not the formula. It's horrible. Matte, dry and clumpy, with lots of fallout. I will wash the brush to keep.

PROS:
the brush has a ball point end which makes it easy to get into the corners
gives alot of volume and length
long lasting and doesn't flake

CONS:
the brush is very big (which i dont mind but i know alot of people do)
it dries quickly so if you get it on the skin you have to use makeup remover to get it off
can get clumpy if too much is applied

A lot of these negative reviews are downright hilarious, if you hated the rest of the scandal eyes mascaras, really why would you spend money on the new one?
**
I love this mascara, I have all the Rimmel mascaras and love them. I angle the large part of the brush to get the lengths, and then use the balled end to work through the base of the lashes to add volume, and also get the smaller lashes that are hard to catch.