Overall, this was an okay mascara. It doesn't give a whole lot of volume and it clumps. However, it is easy to use and looks natural. The packaging is pretty good, aside from the fact that the lid of the actual mascara tube was a little tricky to unscrew. Another con is that it tends to create black smudges under my eyes after several hours. I would not buy this again, but I'd recommend it to someone just starting to use makeup.

This is not really a truly waterproof mascara. After a couple of hours I do have dark smudges under my eyes, and by the end of the day I have more on my skin than on my lashes! The 2 brush options do nothing different to my lashes, and I can't even tell the difference most of the time. I wouldn't buy this again, I want a waterproof mascara that doesn't smudge!