This is a fairly decent product, but overall, it wasn't easy/quick to apply.
Pros: Great price, nice packaging, nice tip
Cons: The formula seemed kind of thin to me. While applying, I would have to press hard and repeatedly line my eyes until the eyeliner would actually show.
LOVE the tip on this pen. Super fine and very easy to make a nice winged eyeliner look. It's not as super black as I would like, but it's definitely buildable.
It was pretty easy to remove using Pond's cold cream and I didn't notice any staining on my eyes after removal. Cold cream or baby oil is best when it comes to removing this one.
For me this eyeliner is great as it has a nice point end. The colour isnt as black as i would like it to be but i cant complain it was $4. Ive only used it a few times because it really doesnt dispense enough product, I needed to go over and over it to get enough product to make a perfect line. Wouldnt recommend this unfortunately
Holy long wearing Batman! This stuff stays on your lids all day and then some unless you're using an oil based eye makeup remover, which I can't.
I had forgotten my eyeliner and mascara so I went to a drugstore nearby and got something el cheapo as I didn't want to spend the money on my usual eyeliner.
The eyeliner is a deep, rich black and it went on really well. (I use liquid pen eyeliners so I have no problems with the application)
But when it came time to take off my makeup, this stuff was stubborn. Even with a few swipes with a Q-tip dipped in eye makeup remover, there were still traces of it.
This would be ideal for those long hour days or photographs but be prepared for tenacious removal. At least it's cheap.
I still prefer my Physician's Formula liquid liners. They go on a bit more smoothly, excellent pigment and easy removal.
The liner is nice and dark, it stayed put even on my super oily lids and the pen point is fine. I thought I wanted a fine liner but this is too fine. I end up talin way too long to apply because it is way too difficult to keep a stady hand, then I end up with doodle-looking lner that I have to fill in. I don't think I will buy again. I hate grief when I put on makeup.
I honestly hated this product. The price was very cheap (3$ CDN) and I got some beautiful swatches of it instore so I decided to buy it. I used to both on a clean eyelid base and a eyeshadow base and was not happy with either results. The applicator was so fine and very thin but barely any got to the top of my brush, and whatever I did get came out as a horrible mess. It dried super fast but when it dries I noticed a huge loss in the pigmentation which was also a huge disapointment. But the worst part of it all was I could not get it off!! I used soap and water, makeup remover wipes, waterproof makeup remover, I tried pretty much everything but was left with uneven, faint, grey stains for almost 3 days. I do not recommend this product at all and to save your money for a much better liquid eyeliner pen.
-Super fine tip, so its very easy to draw a thin line :D (cat eyes ftw!)
-Lots of ink. Ive got it for more than a month, i use it everyday, and I feel like i still have a lot
-The pen is easy to use, not messy
-I have one monolid eye and the other has small lid (yeah its difficult to apply even eye make up x.x), and it doenst smudge on my lid :) Even if my lids are oily
-I was surprised when it stained my eyelid...I cant remove it :o
-When I put water (or cry :() on my lids and whipe it, it becomes blue/purple :O Idk why, its actually scary xD I was worried at first...looks ...toxic o-o
Overall, i really like this eyeliner, and i would repurchase this :) But ill love it more if it didnt stain my lid x.x
Unfortunately, I just chucked this eyeliner pen. The good stuff: 1) the felt tip is super fine 2) it's cheap, costs only $4 in Australia. The bad stuff: heaps of them - 1) the tip of the pen is too soft that you might do an accident flick if it bends 2) the eyeliner stains the eyelid so bad that you can't get it out even with the best waterproof remover, but the stain seems to disappear after a couple of days 3) the ink doesn't flow out smoothly so you would have to go back on the line again and again.
Will not repurchase.
This eyeliner is a bit tricky at first and the tip is a bit soft so you need to be quite steady handed. It gives a lovely solid black colour on my complexion and lasts all day. It does run a bit dry halfway during an application, which is a bit annoying, so be sure to work quick with this liner. Dries quickly and doesn't budge/ smudge even without a primer. So far I would purchase again.
Love this product! It stays waterproof almost all day, so i dont have to worry about smudging eyeliner. Great quality and i will definately be buying this product again :)