Thoroughly removes my waterproof sunblock and bb cream. Leaves a residue if you don't wipe it off properly; however, you can easily follow up with a separate cleanser if you find that your skin feels sticky. I've been using this for about a week and it hasn't broken my combo acne prone skin out.
(11/30/12): Takes a lot of effort in ensuring that it doesn't break me out. Does make my under eye skin plump up a little, which makes me look like I have eye bags. I'm still going to give it a rating of 5 since I think it's a great product. Not sure what I'm going to do with it since I can't use it on my eyes either.