I have to disagree with the person above me- I thought these were incredibly creamy for being a stick liner. Saying that, they didn't last the way I thought they would. I live in a humid climate and have oily lids, so that could come into consideration. I like the colors I got though, in "Blackout" & "Mink".. they were 2 for $6 at ULTA, so not a bad deal.
I have the gel eyeliners in mink (dark brown) majesty ( royal purple) and peacock ( teal). These gel liners are not as soft and creamy as I like. I typically use Revlon Grow Luscious liners or Urban Decay 24/7.