I picked this up at a local mom & pop beauty supply for $1.99. There were so many pretty colors, and I would have bought a bunch of them, but there were no testers so I just picked one to try out. Glad I held back. This is definitely the worst product I've tried in recent memory, beauty or otherwise. This is a deep navy blue cream pencil. It goes on smoothly with nice pigmentation, but it never sets and has no staying power whatsoever. Wipes right off. Seriously, you can rub your fingertip over it three times and it's pretty much gone.