I have to agree with the rave reviews on this lipstick. The formula is so creamy and luxurious. The packaging is beautiful. I ordered mine from Sephora--I live 2 hrs from the nearest Too Faced products. So I really went back and forth before choosing Spice Spice Baby. Very happy I did. Very natural looking color I will get a lot of use out of. Love. Love. Love. Will definitely be back for more.

I ordered this lipstick online and good golly, Miss Molly, if it didn't turn out to be just the most perfect 'natural' lip color for me. Not only does the color work perfectly with my (NW20) complexion, but the texture - oh goodness - the texture is amaaaazing. I can't recall the last time a lipstick went on so effortlessly and remained smooth and creamy for HOURS. Yes, HOURS (the all caps are intentional - it's that good). Color me impressed & happy . . . and now I want more of these lippies! continued >>

I am planning on getting a back up of this lipstick as soon as I can. It is the prettiest shade on my lips. It looks natural and it is very moisturizing and long lasting. It just might be my HG lipstick. It certainly is my favorite right now. It goes on so smoothly as well.
I will have to check out the other colors more carefully but this Spice Spice Baby may be the best of their shades for me.

These lipsticks are quickly becoming some of my all time favorites. This pinky brown is no exception. It amps up my natural lip color a bit and is soooooooooooo moisturizing. I also love the lemon cake scent.

I LOVE THIS SO MUCHHHHH. I bought this after seeing this on Jen's (frmheadtotoe) favorites videos a few times. I've never really liked lipsticks because I don't like the way it dries down and makes my lips crack but this is a WHOLE different story! I saw this at Sephora and tried it on and it was love at first test! It's a really nice my-lips-but-better shade except my lips aren't exactly this color. It is not too pink, or too red, or too brown, or too plum. It's just the perfect mix of everything! The formula itself is very creamy and hydrating. When it dries down it doesn't make my lips crack. The only things bad about this are the price and the fact that it'll probably melt very easily! I left it in my front jean pocket and I was worried that it'd start melting! But this is my HG lipstick which means A LOT because, like previously stated, I'm normally not a lipstick kind of gal. Will be repurchasing until.......forever.

Perfect rosy-peachy-pink brightening color on my NC30 light tan Asian pigmented lips. It is an easy color and compliments all of my pink and coral blushes. Disappointing staying power (2 hours, tops), but the balmy smooth texture is lovely and it wears away evenly. No weird flakes or build-up. It's like the Revlon Lip Butter texture and very comfortable to wear; I could reapply this a few times and didn't feel like i needed lip balm til about 6 hours later. Will buy in other shades!

Holy shit, I believe I've found my first HG lipstick. The color is perfect as an everyday lip color. It's not drying. If goes on nice and creamy. The ingredients are pretty natural. It has a slight, pleasant smell to it. Hope they don't stop making it!
In Canada I paid $25 for it though...damn expensive.

Doesn't last long though, maybe 10 minutes.

I adore this lipstick, it's one I tend to reach for over and over again. It's a lovely subtle colour, a soft pink with slight almost golden brown undertones, very flattering and natural looking. The product formulation is just divine, a soft and easy to apply cream lipstick with glossy sheen. If you wanted to tone down the glossiness a little, blotting does help. Feels amazing on the lip, very moisturising and smooth, but not heavy. It's scented, with a sort of citrus champagne cocktail, which I find pleasant and not overpowering. Great wear length for such a creamy lipstick, and great texture for the lips too. The tube itself is luxurious, which makes this feel all the more special; a gold metal case, slim but heavy with Too Faced embossed on the side, inside of which is the flat topped slanted lipstick. The other colours I've tried in this range are just as delightful, and I'd definitely repurchase when they run out.

This is a long-lasting, moisturizing lipstick that comes in an elegant looking gold twist up container. Even though this is a cream lipstick, it's dewy and soft, and it never looks dry or crusty. Spice Spice Baby is described as a "pinky brown" but, on me, it shows up as a warm terracotta, which I utterly love. I also purchased this in Nice Melons (bright coral) and Naughty Nude (matte peach), and each shade is gorgeous. These have quickly become my all time favorite lipsticks. I will definitely repurchase the shades I own, and I look forward to trying new colors. This formulation hits the ball out of the park!