Smudged on me before I reached work. What a waste of money, found better at Watsons (drugstore).

This liner is crap. Good concept, bad execution. Its smudges in like an hour, and thats with a primer. I have oily skin, and have used the Stila and Kat Von D pens and they last all day long, the 3-way liner ended up smudged in my inner and outer corners of eyes. Very disapointed. You can find a better drugstore liquid felt tip liner, I like the Maybelline Line Stilleto.

Love this liner...once I apply it its there all day! I love the way it makes my lashes look fuller after I apply my mascara. I think to way too pricey for a eyeliner. Does take some practice for the upper lashes I dont use this liner for the lower lashes but overall its not my fav eyeliner and I didnt actually pay for it I brought with a gift card I got Christmas so it actually didnt come from pocket. I used alot of different eyeliners and so far thiss one is doing the job for upper lashes and it gives me killer straight line across my lids when I want to do a classic cat eye!

Meh! The idea of it is genius. I tried it on my upper lid and the pigment is light and you have to go over a couple times. I need to work at the application and see if the results improve.

This eyeliner is supposed to give you a very straight line but it just doesn't work. I tried to give this product a try but it's just not worth buying

Wish I had read reviews of this before purchasing(like I normally do). Great concept for tightlining but this gave me wicked racoon face even when I used it as a normal liner. I have never had this problem with any other liner I've tried. Beyond that, it is one of those eyeliners where the only way to get more product at the tip is to shake it. Not really effective at getting an even spread of liner. In short, cool idea, horrible execution. Returning immediately.

This product doesn't work for me. It smudges just an hour after use and doesn't tightline well with the 3 points. The color is not intense at all.

Great concept! I like to use this to apply it in between my lashes. On my oily lids it lasts all day without smudging. I hope to see it become available in brown.

Giving this a 2 rating for concept only..otherwise I wouldn't have even given it a rating. Liner formula is too wet and it smudges like crazy and really doesn't set well. If the formula were less wet it may have been a keeper. Would definitely make tightlining easier.

I really love how this gets in between lashes. It takes forever to accomplish that with a pencil and then the pencil just dirties up your lashes. This does take a little practice to get the technique down, but once you get the hang of it it's fabulous. What's not fabulous? You'll look like a raccoon. I use primer underneath and powder and it still smudged. I'm going to give it another whirl and make sure I don't get it on my waterline and see what happens. Otherwise I'll return it. Wanted to try the Clarins version but can't seem to track it down.