I was very pleasantly surprised by this! Bought it on a whim while picking out some new lip colors from their re-vamped Beauty Rush line, it was 4 for $20 and even though I have like, a gazillion e/s palettes in brown tones I'm always looking for new palettes that offer slightly different saturations. These are pretty nice quality, just enough shimmer, lasts really well throughout the day and I am finding I currently reach for this palette daily, over my Revlon CustomEyes palette which I thought was all I would ever use from here on out. I really like this one though, maybe they'll offer a few more color trios and expand the line. I went back to buy the purple trio but it looked too bright for me, the other palettes in different color groups, same thing. I'm tempted to buy the new giant e/s palette they came out with too. I have generally had good luck with VS makeup.