I bought the black version of this and was not disappointed at all.
Price: Although it's a little pricey for me, it's completely worth it.
Packaging: I honestly don't pay too much attention to the packaging but it did state a few useful things such as the fact that it is water and smudge proof (WHICH IS GREAT) and it has a picture of it on an eye to give an indication as to how thick the eyeliner is made for.
My eyes do get oily throughout the day and usually at night, after a full day of activities, I find that my eyeliner is still going on strong. So it's good to know that the smudge proof statement is actually quite true. As for waterproof, I have never swam with it on so I'm not sure how that will play out if I ever do swim with it BUT I have accidentally gone in the shower with it on but found that most of the eyeliner was still there. I think as long as you don't rub your eyelids while it's really wet then you're good. Under the rain or getting accidental splashes on your eyelids won't do much harm to the eyeliner - just make sure to do a touch up.
It's a very good product in my opinion and I will always go back to repurchase.
I got this while I was on holiday in Asia for around £4/$6USD/$7AUD and it was well worth it! The packaging is typical Maybelline eyeliner packaging, so nothing new. My eyelids do tend to get oily, especially if it's a bit hot out and this stays, surprisingly! It isn't the BLACKEST eyeliner I've used but definitely doesn't have a gray-ish kind of appearance like alot of eyeliners do. I really enjoy the fact that the tip of the eyeliner pen is very precise, so extremely easy to get your eyeliner matching.. Especially if your daily eyeliner is a cat eye! Would definitely recommend, however I can't find this back home :(
I bought it because of the cheap prize and the pen. I can't use liquid eyeliner, since it's like the pen, i can use this easily :") It last all day and nice pigmentation.
BUT TODAY, today is very hot day. The eyeliner melted and smudged under my eyes, I have dark circles, this eyeliner make dark circles like 2 or 3 shades darker 3 It vanished about 30minutes, really disappeared just darker eyes. The packaging is practical, and the prize is cheap, worth your money, because it's good & last in normal weather, but it went worse in hot weather, (I have an oily eyelids, maybe in hot weather I must wear eye primer) I think I am not buy again, because I want to try another brand or another type of eyeliner.
I love this liquid eyeliner! In fact, I love it so much I have backups! It's a very smooth, pigmented eyeliner with a very thin precise tip that makes it perfect for lining your top lid, and building up the thickness of your line as you go along. It doesn't stray or melt during the day and has proven to be quite waterproof - very important to me as I live in a very humid city! If you're looking for an affordable, effective eyeliner I would recommend you to try this one from Maybelline.
I've removed 2 lippies from this as I've found better. I noticed flaws from this ever since I tried out Heroine Makeup's Liquid Eyeliner (It's amazing). Upon comparison, Maybelline's hyper sharp liner, isn't the sharpest, it isn't the most pigmented, and takes quite a while to dry - which doesn't bode well for those without much lid space as it will transfer if you don't give it a minute to settle. Also, it isn't the prettiest after a night out. Heroine Makeup's eyeliner doesn't have any of these problems, so I wouldn't be repurchasing Maybelline's hyper sharp liner in the future!
I bought this at the drugstore and this was the only one available at the Maybelline counter. This works pretty well because it has a fine brush which works to define your eyes while allowing you to apply close to the lashline. The only thing I dislike about this is that it has a tendency to smudge, especially at the outer ends of the eye. When I do a wingtip, a few hours later I can see a slight smudge underneath. Ugh. Other than that, I really love the brush applicator. I just wish it was more long-lasting and smudge-proof.
I love this product! I'm currently wearing it everyday.. The price is reasonable for the quality and I will definitely buy it again!
this is to me an awesome pen eyeliner. the pen is very thib which makes it easier to draw a line. for those who looks for a jet black color, this may not be for you since the pen is extra thin, you need to fill it in with another black liquid/gel liner. but i love this. perfect for an everyday eyeliner