This is one of the worst eye pencils I had ever had. Usually I wear this on days Im in rush and I do not care how good (or bad) my make up is. I usually now thsi eye pencil wear smear off and it will be easy to remove it (as it's not waterproof, not even hot days proof). I have had it for many years, but now decided to write a review for myself (not to purchase it again) and will throw it away.