For $3 on clearance at Sephora it was worth a shot. Not a vivid blue when applied. Not even a navy blue. It almost looks muted and has a grayish-blue tinge when it goes on. The blunt point makes it impossible to make a really sharp defined line - it goes on more smokey and smudges fairly easily. Very compact so easy to travel with - but if you want a precise line, skip this one. Glad I did not pay full price for this. I'll save my next $3 to apply to the cost of a different kohl liner.
not terrible, not great. i bought it cuz it was on sale $5. it's an odd shape: kind of a tall pyramid in a twist up tube. not very sanitary cuz you can't sharpen it + how do you keep it pointy? i guess it's kohl so it doesn't have to be precisely sharp, but the product still gets wider towards the base. i was hoping for a dark navy blue, but it's lighter than that, maybe a dark marine blue, not at all bold or rich. some smudging, even with primer, which is not helpful; i need to reapply it every few hours to keep the line near my eyes dark. haven't tried it on my waterline cuz it smudged off the upper lid, didn't seem worth trying.