These are pretty bad.
They do remove eyeshadow, but they are not very gentle. Mascara is very hard to remove with these
They claim to remove even waterproof mascara - but they just don't. No matter how hard I rubbed, it wouldn't come off and it only left me with irritated eyes.
The packagaing is lovely, but that's about it.
I feel like they are not "wet" enough somehow, that's why they are so rough on the skin.
I would definitely not repurchase them.